RPGShadow's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[FAUX - Chapter 5]

AT LAST!!

you are ANIMATING! YES!!!1 this is fantastic.

I really enjoy your story since chapter 1, I was hoping that you would give it the treatment that your story truly deserves with Proper animation and here you are doing that, now that series will prosper well.

Are you going to do the same for the earlier chapters? or are you going to do that when you'll have more free time? since I'm sure that you are really busy animating the rest of the chapters.

^_^

marsoupskin responds:

Thank you. I'm not against the idea perhaps someday in the future. But as you say, I'd rather concentrate on moving forward.

[FAUX: Chapter 4]

the animation greatly lacks

it's as if instead of going forwards in original indie animation, we are going backwards and even then in the early days (let's say 1999), Zhu was doing his Xiao Xiao animations wich were incredible for its time and for the basic tools that he had. If we go even further in indie animation we'll come across to some early animators doing shorts and these are some of the most classics in animation history. and I read some people's comment defending this as this being just because it's a "motion comic", do you know when this was last used(before the internet, I say)? Maybe 1920 or even earlier with 1 or 2 comics (I only saw clips for Captain America), that was when it was expensive to make animation...(you had to do it on a celuloid before and that thing is small to work with as you can imagine).

Now with a less expensive way to make animation and even free alternatives to make them, you should at least do a better effort to make some KIND of animation, when you're in newgrounds it is an Unwritten DUTY to do so.

I have only seen this kind of animation aborration with ONLY adaptations from existing web-comic series. I'm sure that the creators of said-webcomics are glad that they are getting "some" kind of new audience but i'm only saying that you'd also WANT to be proud of the animated version since you put so much work into the core of your idea( witch is your webcomic).

Wich(sorry I'm not sure how to write that word correctly :P) brings to the defendors of this (if we have to really call it that way) "style" of animation, you really have to put your bar really low for being supportive of this setback to the evolution of animation and indie creation. You are 100% Wrong to support this "animation". I see that you want to support the IDEA, but for this kind of well-made narrative it HAS to have animation that matches or the show will just Die, no matter what it will do for being such an unnwatchable mess of moving still frames.

Finally the only reason I am giving a it 1 it is because I went and SUFFERED through the original three episodes and the story holded up greatly (as with many "motion comics")...

that is all

:P

-RPG

[FAUX - trailer]

the animation greatly lacks

it's as if instead of going forwards in original indie animation, we are going backwards and even then in the early days (let's say 1999), Zhu was doing his Xiao Xiao animations wich were incredible for its time and for the basic tools that he had. If we go even further in indie animation we'll come across to some early animators doing shorts and these are some of the most classics in animation history. and I read some people's comment defending this as this being just because it's a "motion comic", do you know when this was last used(before the internet, I say)? Maybe 1920 or even earlier with 1 or 2 comics (I only saw clips for Captain America), that was when it was expensive to make animation...(you had to do it on a celuloid before and that thing is small to work with as you can imagine).

Now with a less expensive way to make animation and even free alternatives to make them, you should at least do a better effort to make some KIND of animation, when you're in newgrounds it is an Unwritten DUTY to do so.

I have only seen this kind of animation aborration with ONLY adaptations from existing web-comic series. I'm sure that the creators of said-webcomics are glad that they are getting "some" kind of new audience but i'm only saying that you'd also WANT to be proud of the animated version since you put so much work into the core of your idea( witch is your webcomic).

Wich(sorry I'm not sure how to write that word correctly :P) brings to the defendors of this (if we have to really call it that way) "style" of animation, you really have to put your bar really low for being supportive of this setback to the evolution of animation and indie creation. You are 100% Wrong to support this "animation". I see that you want to support the IDEA, but for this kind of well-made narrative it HAS to have animation that matches or the show will just Die, no matter what it will do for being such an unnwatchable mess of moving still frames.

Finnally the only reason I am giving a it 2 it is because I went and SUFFERED through the original three episodes and the story holded up greatly (as with many "motion comics")...

that is all :P

-RPG

[Smokin']

I remember these days....

and I never tought anything wrong of it.....it smelled kinda good but it would make me cough a litle .....I would'nt try it since ....... well maybe I'll try ......nope.....

:P

vakavadesigns responds:

Ever try those wacky electronic cigarettes? It's not a suggest... just saying...

[A Aa A Aaa Aaa A Aa Aa Aa]

aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhh

that was teh sound of mah orgasmic jizz..... yes my jizz just orgasmedz.........zezezeezezezezezeze ezeze

:P

[Come Back to Me]

WAIT!!!...

Who took the photos of them together...?
LOL
:P
Well the this was really well made I want to do things like that...but I'm not...good enough...
:P

[Vending Machine and Me]

I know your pain!...

Except that my problem is with soda vending machines...

Great short it was hilarious, especialy the part were he punches it around the globe...

:P

[How 2 Make a Ngs Username]

HA!...

My name is not made of an adjective but my INITIALS.
(and a noun)
:P

And thaks for that tutorial, now In the future I won't see another 11122212121112 or bbdisdya (I'm serious those are real names) DX
:P

[L'origine des tarlas]

Ben la, criss... (in english)Fuck man...

Regarde pis lis moé ben, Me semble qu`avoir soumis ton beau travail, sur un site AMERICAIN, seulement en français sans maudits sous-titres anglais fait peut-être de toi un plus gros TARLA que le criss de tarla dans ton flash.
Là que que jais fini de te chier dessus, je voudrais te dire que c`était trop drôle pis vraiment con. Beau travail mis a part ton "move" de tarla expliqué dans le dernier paragraphe.
Finalement, si tu ne tiens aucune rancûne pour la chiennerie que je t`ai dis je voudrais savoir à quel college ou cegep que tu y vas et/ou avec quel programme que tu travaille avec. Tu m`enverras un pm(personnal message)sur ma page, merci à l`avance...

P.S.: je traduiras cette critique en anglais pour que TOUT LE MONDE ME COMPRENNE...

:P

(IN ENGLISH)see and read me well. I think that submitting, in an AMERICAN site, only in french without any fucking english subtitles makes you an even bigger MORON(TARLA) than the fucking moron(tarla) in your flash.
Now that I`ve finished dissing you, I`ve got to say that it was fucking hilarious. Good work exept for your moronic move mentioned in the last paragraph.

P.S.:I`m gonna translate this review so that EVERYONE CAN UNDERSTAND...
:P

[- Move Your Feet -]

to the guy below me...

it`s TOFU!!!

and the video made me move MY feets on dance dance Revolution LOOOOOL!!!

:P